Is All My Darling Daughters (due this week from Viz Media) the best comic Fumi Yoshinaga has ever created? Of course it isn’t. It’s not as ambitious as Ôoku: The Inner Chambers, as funny as Flower of Life, or as sexy as Ichigenme… The First Class Is Civil Law.
Should you buy All My Darling Daughters? Of course you should. It’s by Yoshinaga, so it’s still funnier, smarter and warmer than most comics you’re likely to encounter.
The book collects interconnected short stories that spoke out from an adult daughter and her mother. They live together until the mother remarries a much younger man she met in a host club. Your automatic assumption might be that the mother is in the midst of a mid-life crisis or that the husband is looking for a meal ticket, and the daughter would agree with you. I remind you that this is Yoshinaga, so it’s more complicated than that.
Everything is more complicated than it seems in Yoshinaga’s narrative universe. People are both nicer and meaner than they initially seem, and relationships are more quietly satisfying and functional than an observer might assume. Yoshinaga is deeply interested in the grace notes of interpersonal interaction, even in her slighter works. That’s the source of a lot of the pleasure for me – the apparently minor, digressive moments that get to the heart of her characters.
I enjoyed all of the pieces collected here, but my favorite was a two-part look at a beautiful, selfless young woman who decides to pursue an arranged marriage. It works very nicely as a comedy of nightmare dating, but it evolves into a much richer character study. It’s sweet, funny and, by the end, surprisingly sad, but sad in a way I can absolutely support.
While she’s not in every story, Mari, the mother, is a treasure. She’s a survivor, but she’s got self-esteem issues. She can be abrasive, but her honesty never fails to be refreshing and sometimes even useful. I smiled a little every time she showed up, knowing she’d provide some withering observation on the endearing flakes around her, a flash of unexpected tenderness, or both. Of all the men and women portrayed here, she best embodies the aspects of life that interest Yoshinaga – work, family, love, and the resentment and solace they can provide.
All My Darling Daughters ran in Hakusensha’s Melody magazine, an older-skewing shôjo magazine that’s home to Ôoku. I’m not all that familiar with the magazine’s output, but Yoshinaga’s participation is certainly enough to put it on my radar.
(This review is based on a complimentary copy provided by the publisher.)
[…] (Soliloquy in Blue) Holly Ellingwood on All My Darling Daughters (Active Anime) David Welsh on All My Darling Daughters (Precocious Curmudgeon) Lorena Nava Ruggero on vol. 2 of Black Bird (i heart manga) Johanna Draper […]
[…] David Welsh’s review includes some sample art panels. The publisher provided a review copy. Similar Posts: The Color of Earth, The Color of Water, The Color of Heaven § *Naoki Urasawa’s Monster Book 1 — Recommended § *Nana Book 9 — Recommended § Confessions of a Blabbermouth § Kamikaze Girls […]
Thank you for this review. Yet another Yoshinaga that will be a must read.
While I have not enjoyed everything I have read by her, the body of her work is stunning. I am currently reading Ooku, I was blindsided by what I consider to be a brilliant work. Another is Solfege, a personal favorite, which I feel got lost in the race to publish so many of her works, a few years ago.
[…] both David Welsh and Johanna Draper Carlson review Fumi Yoshinaga’s All My Darling Daughters this morning! […]
Man, what are the rest of us poor schlubs going to say when we get around to reviewing All My Darling Daughters? File this under “Another Review by David That I Wish I’d Written!”
You’re too kind as always, Kate, but thanks!
And Judi, now I’ll have to revisit Solfege, which I first read in the midst of a big stack of Yoshinaga.
[…] Signature week. As I mentioned, I’ve already blathered on about not simple and Fumi Yoshinaga’s All My Darling Daughters, and you’d think those two comics would be enough for any publisher in a given week, but wait, as […]
Woohoo! Thought you’d like this, David, and I’m pleased to see I wasn’t wrong.
The episode you single out was my favourite story, too – the final twist was unexpected and yet completely logical…
JennyN: Those chapters were good throughout, but the twist ending was pure Yoshinaga — surprising but utterly true to her characters. It really locked it into first place for me.
[…] Both Johanna Draper Carlson and David Welsh recommend All My Darling Daughters. Welsh also takes a look at the work of Natsume Ono over at […]
[…] And here’s my review. […]
[…] (VIZ) has garnered plenty of praise for its witty dialogue and memorable characters. In his review, David Welsh gives Daughters high marks for the complexity and depth of the stories: Everything is more […]
[…] by Fumi Yoshinaga (Viz): This book has garnered a lot of critical acclaim since its release, some of it from me: “Everything is more complicated than it seems in Yoshinaga’s narrative universe. People are […]