MMF: Setting sail

Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece (Viz) is a shônen manga about pirates. As a child, Luffy D. Monkey grows up in a seaside village that serves as a sort of off-duty destination for a group of pirates led by Red-Haired Shanks. Enthralled by the Red-Haired Pirates’ tales of adventure, Luffy determines to become a pirate himself, even after he encounters a less benevolent group of pirates.

Since this is shônen manga, where dreams are nothing if not big, Luffy determines not only to become a pirate, but to become the king of the pirates and find the legendary treasure, the titular “One Piece.” Of course, Luffy has a bit of a handicap for a seafarer. He consumed one of the mysterious “devil fruits” that give those who consume them amazing, often bizarre powers but rob them of the ability to swim a stroke. And, if shônen is about big dreams, it’s also about overcoming obstacles. And an innate tendency to drown is certainly an obstacle for a pirate.

Shônen manga is also about making friends, more often than not, and Luffy is a gregarious sort. While he starts with a raft and a souvenir hat from Shanks, he quickly acquires the beginnings of a crew and a sturdy ship for them to sail. He’ll need both as he sets off into increasingly dangerous waters and encounters with formidable rivals. But Luffy and crew are no slouches; they can hold their own in tough spots.

If this all sounds like pretty standard adventure comics for boys, it doesn’t factor in Oda’s comedic idiosyncrasy or his facility for surprising drama. One Piece has big battle set pieces, but it doesn’t have the conventional storytelling rhythms of the genre. Oda rarely asks his audiences to endure any sequence that overstays its welcome. His ability to build appealing, sympathetic and diverse characters is matched by his sure hand with moving the narrative around though a number of different perspectives. Storylines can run for a number of volumes, but they never feel too long, since Oda can jump around with point of view so easily.

The series is insanely commercially successful in Japan. According to Anime News Network,

“The market survey firm Oricon reports that the 60th volume of Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece pirate manga sold 2,094,123 copies between its first official day of sales (November 4) and November 7. It is the first book to sell over 2 million copies in its first week of sales since Oricon began reporting its book ranking charts in April of 2008. This volume topped the previous first-week sales record held by the 59th volume, which sold 1,852,541 copies in August.”

Oda seems to be making a hobby of new sales milestones. The series has a successful anime adaptation, and there have been a number of special book products supporting the franchise. But it’s hard not to conclude that its commercial success comes from genuine fondness. For all of Oda’s playing around with tone and narrative, it’s ultimately an old-fashioned, good-natured property. It’s perhaps not surprising that Oda cites Akira (Dragon Ball) Toriyama as an inspiration.

One Piece has run in Shueisha’s Weekly Shônen Jump since 1997, and it’s part of the line-up of Viz’s Shonen Jump magazine, along with titles like Naruto and Bleach. It’s not nearly as popular in North America, though Viz did give it a run of accelerated release recently, allowing it to close in on its Japanese release schedule, not unlike the “Naruto Nation” initiative of a few years back. Perhaps some of the pieces that are posted this week will explore some of the reasons why the series isn’t a North American smash proportional to its hometown popularity.

I’ll post daily link updates starting tomorrow, and I’ll update this blog page regularly as well. Please email me when you’ve posted something for the feast, and, if you’re on Twitter, use the #MMF hashtag if you think of it. I’m looking forward to reading and hearing everyone’s thoughts about this series!

7 Responses to MMF: Setting sail

  1. […] Arrrrrr! The December Manga Movable Feast is underway, and the subject is Eiichiro Oda’s wildly popular One Piece, currently the […]

  2. I think a big reason for One Piece being less successful in North America than Naruto but being a blockbuster overseas has to do with the original 4 Kids dub. For many people, thanks to Fox Saturday Morning lineup and Cartoon Network, the 4 Kids! dub was the first exposure for many to One Piece, and it was so atrociously butchered it probably soured many people to giving it a second chance. For North American shonen readers, it seems that many discover the anime first on TV then search out the books. Naruto’s anime not only has had a much better English dub in America, it’s been airing consistently for years on American airwaves to this day.

    • davidpwelsh says:

      I have only scant memories of the anime as it aired on Saturday mornings, but those memories aren’t pleasant, so I think you’re onto something here. (And I also have liked what I’ve seen of the Fullmetal Alchemist anime, so that would support the other side of the equation: good anime treated well = higher manga sales.)

  3. And actually, I can think of one One Piece arc that overstayed its welcome, at least in my opinion, and that’s the Skypeia arc. It ended on a strong note, but a lot of it was just way too long on explanatory exposition.

    • davidpwelsh says:

      I loved the back half of the Skypeia arc, I have to admit, if only for the sad flashback. I’m a huge sucker for Oda’s sad flashbacks.

      • Yes, I agree the back half was spectacular and more than made up for the first half. That flashback was awesome. I should have specified, the FIRST HALF of the Skypeia arc overstayed its welcome.

  4. […] love it deserves. It’s hosted by David Welsh of Manga Curmudgeon. You can read the intro post here, and the archive of all the participants here. And there are a lot of posts to read, covering a […]

%d bloggers like this: